the brief
the second eponymous karosong, on lessons learned, absorbed and released in the end of a 24-year marriage
From day one, karosongs have used my emotions to embed themselves in me. Most songs have been a roller coaster of emotional turmoil, realization and resolution. They have helped me process the past, let go of shit, grow and move towards self-awareness.
The rain must fall did it in the present and in real time.
yes i know it’s time, it’s time to say goodbye
i know we're broke and ain't no way to fix it
and yeah i know you gotta get a move on
so it's time to hit the road jack
get my ass moving, get this truck in gear
My wife Ellen informed me in April 2017 that she wanted to separate. I was not expecting it, was not prepared for it. It sent me into a dark, despondent place.
After some weeks, I started getting lyrics to a song on my maybes youtube playlist — a live version of Yanni's beautiful The Rain Must Fall.
It was the 25th karosong to start channeling, the first entirely original 3.0-type asynchronous collaboration, and the first karosong that shared the same title as its async partner.
but i never thought i'd see this day
standing here at the end of this driveway
about to say adieu . . .
so before we do i just want to say
that i don't regret our marriage
and i don't regret our years
and no i don't regret the passions
the joys not even the sorrows
It was a difficult song for a difficult period. As the lyrics came, there were tears, choking up, more tears, more choking up. I was living on the knife edge of my emotions, afraid I might fall off any time.
But I was processing those emotions as they came, coming to acceptance, even a kind of peace with it all. Eventually.
i accept
i accept but regret that it's ending
a path breaks into two and each moves on to
futures that suddenly do not include the other
who'da thunk it eh? still. . .
so many years we shared the sun
so many years we shared the fun
so many years we shared the . . .
ah what's the point . . .
Song titles usually have great emotional power for me, particularly when they appear in the lyrics. Especially, for me as a writer, when they are fused into a simply gorgeous metaphor.
And inevitably when they encapsulate both my inner world and the song itself.
for yes i know
the rain must fall
for life to renew itself
tears are our rain
may they renew you
It was months before I could get through those lines without choking up.
But that was the song's fulcrum, lyrically and emotionally. As the next sections clarified, I saw that the song was me coming to terms with the end of my marriage. And then letting go of it.
some of the things
some of the things i do regret
are things i couldn't change
but to be fair some of them
were things i could have changed
if i'd wanted
i guess i didn't
enough
As the lyrics were coming in, that process of coming to terms was actually happening inside me in my 'real' life. It was as though the song was leading me through the process of accepting and letting go. Suppporting me. Expediting it too.
and i am sorry for both and
sorry for the many ways I hurt and
disappointed you
we diminish by the small failures
as well as the big ones
and death by either
or any mixture between
hurts just as much
hurts just this much
I was working with a live version of Yanni's The Rain Must Fall from youtube. It was quite a bit longer than the finished karosong, but the karosong lyrics neatly ended just as Yanni's orchestra went into high-paced solo-swapping. (There's probably a term for that too.) There was exactly enough time in the transition for a final word and toast to life.
meanwhile as i pulled out of the driveway
the last line of our short song over
on the radio the long song
played on
The karosong ended, but life went on.
Post-script
This was always a difficult song to sing because of the difficult emotions behind it, the raw hurt, wounded self, the sorrow, the loss. Even so, it was one of the first 3.1 songs to be 'released' — meaning sent out as a 'demo' to a very few people.
the lyrics
. . . opening credits
The rain must fall
a lyric / musical pas de deux
by Yanni and his brilliant orchestra
with 3.2 lyrics by karo
from 'how do' to 'i do' to 'adieu'
the short version
for ellen
— 1 —
yes i know it’s time
i know it’s time to say goodbye
i know we're broke and ain't no way to fix it
and yeah i know you gotta get a move on, so it's time
to hit the road jack, get my ass moving
get this truck in gear
but i never thought i'd see this day
standing here at the end of this driveway
about to say adieu ...
so before we do i just want to say
. . . chorusthat i don't regret our marriage
and i don't regret our years
and no i don't regret the passions
the joys not even the sorrows
no i don't regret them
— 2 —
i accept
i accept but regret that it's ending
. . . a path breaks into two and each moves on to
futures that suddenly do not include the other
who'da thunk it eh? well
anyone perceptive . . .
apparently
still. . .
so many years we shared the sun
so many years we shared the fun
so many years we shared the . . .
ah what's the point . . .
for yes i know
the rain must fall for life to renew itself
tears are our rain
may they renew you
but don't sell us short and forget the strength
and strengths we found together, and the common loves we shared
and don't forget the homes we built
the children we helped each other parent
we accomplished much
only fools would call that failure
— 3 —
. . . versesome of the things
some of the things i do regret
are things i couldn't change
but to be fair some of them
were things i could have changed
if i'd wanted
i guess i didn't
enough
and i am sorry for both and
sorry for the many ways I hurt and
disappointed you
we diminish by the small failures
as well as the big ones
and death by either — or any mixture between —
hurts just as much
hurts just this much
so i'll say goodbye now
farewell gotta go
adieu
. . . chorus like buildand no i don't regret our marriage
and i don't regret our years
and no i don't regret the passions
the joys not even the sorrows
no i don't regret our life together
the good times, the life events happy and sad we shared
and all the things in between
no i don't regret them
can’t ever
won’t ever
still, like you, i am ready to move on
to say adieu
meanwhile as i pulled out of the driveway
— the last line of our short song over —
on the radio
the long song played on
the vault
The rain must fall is a youtube karosong that first channeled during the period I wasn't doing any recording. So it was almost 2 years before there was a 'release' quality recording of the song.
arc01 / first 'release' — June 20, 2019 [6]
The song was close to mastered by the fall of 2019, but even then there were still sections that didn't feel quite right, including the closing refrains.
arc03 / second 'release' — mid September 2019 [7]
Those 'not quite right' sections didn't go away. They waited two years before finalizing as I worked to bring this song into the whole/full karo vox. The changes were not quite mastered before I shut the house down in November of 2021.
arc04 / current — recorded mid October 2021 [7]